The very best toaster oven is the one you may hate the least

For generations, the toaster oven has been a trusty, crusty countertop companion for toasting and baking, an equipment that additionally doubles as a second, smaller oven that boasts sooner heating (and reheating) instances than your primary one.

However should you’re right here to search out the perfect toaster oven, the one which you should purchase instantly with one click on, effectively… I am sorry to say I’ve obtained some disappointing information for you. Toaster ovens are, in my humble opinion, totally overrated.

Possibly that is a tough fact to listen to. The issue is that the majority meals you’d need to toast, like bread or bagels, can be higher off in a normal toaster, and most meals you’d need to bake would end up higher sitting on an oven rack in your traditional oven, the place it will profit from a a lot stronger set of heating parts. Both means, you are compromising from the get-go. And good luck cooking a roast or different sophisticated and time-intensive meals in a countertop toaster oven, even when they do have the correct temperature vary.

Most toaster ovens are cumbersome as hell, too — and due to the rise of kitchen-friendly smart displaysfood processors, Instant Potssous vide cookers, and the like, the possibilities are good that you’ve a greater technique to put that valuable counter area to make use of.

Learn extra: Top bread machines for home bakers 

Nonetheless, possibly you do not have a standard oven and want a countertop toaster oven — or possibly you simply need one, dammit. I get it! Regardless of my misgivings, there’s nonetheless quite a bit to love in regards to the issues. It is a much-beloved kitchen equipment we’re speaking about, and my toasty sizzling take might be a minority report.

However splurging does not at all times make sense. Do you really want so as to add in fashionable luxuries like bar code scanners, built-in meals cameras and sensible cooking help? Techie toaster ovens from names resembling TovalaJune and Brava can value anyplace from $300 to $995, however a lot of the extras present in a mini smart oven are above and past what a median kitchen wants.

Now taking part in:
Watch this:

The best way to purchase a toaster oven that is not horrible


Extra cheap are “improve choose” toaster ovens such because the enjoyable, well-calibrated Panasonic FlashXpress, or a sturdy stalwart just like the Breville Smart Oven, each of which we reviewed — and liked — just a few years in the past. However at $127 and $299 respectively, these fashions, too, are outdoors the mainstream in a world the place a daily toaster could be had for less than $20

Learn extra: 4 signs it’s time to replace your toaster oven

That is why I made a decision to check out a few of your less-expensive choices to see if I may discover a good worth. I honed in on standard, well-reviewed fashions that value between $50 and $100, and I used convection heating — a trick that makes use of a fan to flow into the recent air to toast and prepare dinner in a extra even style — as a baseline, must-have function.

Then, with six toaster ovens able to go in our take a look at kitchen, I got down to put them to the take a look at to attempt to discover the perfect of the lot. Of those six, we got here away with a transparent favourite, and we’re additionally together with the aforementioned Panasonic and Breville toaster ovens as a result of they continue to be effectively definitely worth the splurge.

We have examined all of these aforementioned improve picks right here at CNET Home equipment, however the one one any of us has ever purchased for ourselves is the FlashXpress. It is a enjoyable, quirky countertop cooker that makes use of an infrared heating factor for duties like toasting bread and baking frozen pizza with speedy precision, and it has an simply detachable crumb tray. It may not be sufficiently big for everyone (or for baking for everyone), however that additionally implies that it will not take up any extra counter area than it wants in your countertop. Even now, six years after we first reviewed it, it is nonetheless straightforward to suggest it as the perfect toaster oven for toasting or baking meals, or perhaps a countertop toaster oven improve.

Read our full Panasonic FlashXpress review.

Chris Monroe/CNET

The Breville BOV800XL undoubtedly is not low-cost at round $270, and there is nothing “sensible” in regards to the sensible oven in a cloud-connected sense. However the Breville Sensible Oven Professional cooks nearly the whole lot about in addition to you possibly can probably count on from a countertop convection oven. On high of that, the mini sensible oven is sturdy, engaging, and has an simply detachable crumb tray, and it is filled with further cooking setting modes that you simply would possibly truly discover helpful, together with convection cooking. This Breville Sensible Oven is a good compact toaster oven choose if you do not have a wise oven, do not have room for a full dimension oven or should you plan on utilizing your oven toaster for cooking meals nearly day-after-day.

Read our full Breville Smart Oven review.

Tyler Lizenby/CNET

I hate that the door on this convection toaster oven opens down greater than 90 levels. The glass can crash straight towards the nook of your countertop if it is not pushed all the way in which again towards your backsplash.

Nonetheless, should you can forgive that design flaw, then you definitely’ll love the way in which this convection toaster oven cooks, whether or not you are toasting, baking or broiling. Accessible for about $60 at Costco, this countertop oven was a high finisher in every considered one of our cooking assessments. That type of dependable, predictable cooking and baking is strictly what you need out of your toaster oven.

Editor’s be aware, Jan. 18, 2021: The Oster TSSTTVCG05 seems to have been discontinued. The 2 closest options are the Oster TSSTTVDFL2-AF ($60) and the Oster TSSTTVF816 ($70).

Different toaster ovens we examined

  • Bialetti 35047: This countertop oven mannequin was considered one of our high worth picks of 2019 for its robust options and fashionable design. Sadly, it does not appear to be accessible any longer, a minimum of not at any of the web retailers we monitor. It is not even listed on the Bialetti web site anymore.
  • Black & Decker TO3265XSSD: One of many latest fashions from the highest identify in toaster ovens replaces the convection bake setting with a gimmicky, one-temperature-fits-all “Air Fry” mode. It is tremendous for the worth should you want a wide-bodied design with further room for toast.
  • Hamilton Seaside 31123D: One in all Hamilton Seaside’s “Straightforward Attain” fashions, the marginally under-powered 31123D makes it a bit of simpler to see inside as you are cooking or broiling, due to a sloping “Straightforward Attain” door that lifts as much as open. Too dangerous Hamilton Seaside stamped a big brand on the glass to impede your view.
  • Nostalgia Retro RTOV220RETRORED: The tacky, retro-red design makes it look extra like a toolbox than a toaster oven, and it felt a bit cheaply made. Nonetheless, this eye-catching mannequin carried out passably effectively in our assessments. 
  • Toshiba AC25CEW-BS: The digital controls are good to have on this fancy-looking, black chrome steel choice, however it comes with a studying curve due to underpowered toasting and overpowered baking and broiling.

Extra from Chowhound: 10 toaster oven hacks you need to try right now

Vitality Draw 1,800W 1,500W 1,500W 1,500W 1,500W 1,500W
Settings 9 (Toast, Bake, Broil, Heat, Bagel, Pizza, Cookies, Defrost, Reheat) 4 (Toast, Bake, Broil, Air Fry) 4 (Bake, Toast, Broil, Convection) 4 (Bake, Pizza/Toast, Broil, Convection) 5 (Bake, Toast, Broil, Heat, Turbo) 10 (Bake, Toast, Broil, Convection, Pizza, Cookies, Rotisserie, Defrost, Reheat, Preserve Heat)
Toast time, 2 slices, medium setting 5:00 4:00 3:30 5:30 4:30 3:20
Toast time, 2 slices, darkish setting 8:00 8:00 6:30 9:00 7:30 4:30
Exterior Dimensions 19.7 x 15.8 x 14.2 in. 21.5 x 23.0 x 11.2 in. 9.4 x 18.7 x 15.2 in. 19.2 x 15.4 x 10.8 in. 18.5 x 15.7 x 10.4 in. 19.0 x 10.8 x 15.6 in.
Inside Width 12 in. 16 in. 12 in. 12.5 in. 12 in. 12.5 in.
Inside Depth 12 in. 12 in. 12 in. 12 in. 12 in. 12 in.
Inside Top (from backside rack place) 7.5 in. 7.5 in. 5 in. 7 in. 6 in. 7 in.
Broil Top (from high rack place) 2.5 in. 2 in. 3.5 in. 4 in. 4 in. 2 in.
Weight 18.0 lbs. 19.0 lbs. 14.0 lbs. 15.6 lbs. 14.9 lbs. 16.2 lbs.
Shade Black Stainless Metal Stainless Metal Stainless Metal Crimson Stainless Metal Black Stainless Metal
Key Options “A Little Further” button Mesh air-frying rack “Straightforward Attain” door Retro design None Constructed-in rotisserie cooker
Guarantee 1-year 2-year 1-year 1-year 1-year 1-year
Worth $90 $79 $69 $99 $64 $99 

What are my choices?

You’ve got obtained completely no scarcity of toaster ovens to select from. Names like Black & Decker, Hamilton Seaside, Oster and numerous others have been cranking the issues out for generations now.

The true bargain-bin picks value lower than $50. When you’re keen to spend a bit of extra, you must count on to get some type of convection warmth and cooking, in addition to maybe a wider oven cavity, just a few further cooking preset choices, digital controls, a non-stick coating on the bake pan or a nicer-looking design. The Bialetti and Toshiba fashions I examined are available black chrome steel, matching a contemporary giant equipment pattern, and the Toshiba mannequin encompasses a built-in rotisserie rack, too. The Nostalgia mannequin provides a novel, red-bodied construct, whereas lower-cost choices from Hamilton Seaside and Oster function easier funds picks.

How we examined toaster ovens

Testing toaster ovens requires an terrible lot of cooking, so I donned my trusty tan apron and started working. 

Particularly, I got down to prepare dinner all kinds of frequent toaster oven fodder. Aside from the toasting assessments, the place I checked out every toaster oven’s particular person settings for gentle, medium and darkish toast, I used standardized temperature and prepare dinner instances, and adopted the suggestions on the field for no matter I used to be cooking wherever attainable.

Extra from Chowhound: How to Clean Your Toaster Oven

Ry Crist/CNET

Toast assessments galore

Bread made up the majority of my take a look at fodder — in any case, of all of the meals most of us most likely make most frequently with this stuff it is toast.

Most low-end toaster ovens use a built-in kitchen timer to set the broiling, toasting and cooking time. Sometimes, these timers embody a few preset choices for toasting — medium toast, darkish toast and in some circumstances, a setting for gentle, barely toasted bread, too. 

Fancier fashions with an LCD show will normally allow you to dial into a particular doneness stage if you’re toasting. You may usually get about six or seven settings to select from with these, every with preprogrammed toasting instances. That is extra exact than turning a timer knob, and value it should you’re a stickler for the right shade of golden brown.

For my functions, I toasted two slices of skinny, white sandwich bread in every toaster oven at its model of every of the three frequent settings: gentle, medium and darkish. After every take a look at, I photographed the outcomes and made certain to let the toaster oven cool again right down to room temperature earlier than testing once more.

The principle factor I used to be on the lookout for was a pleasant, even colour at medium settings, in addition to the flexibility to simply modify up or down from there.

The fashions with digital shows — Bialetti and Toshiba — have been the simplest to make use of, because you dial into your most well-liked stage of doneness on a six- or seven-point scale reasonably than guesstimating with a timer knob. 4 out of seven was a contact too darkish for my tastes with Bialetti, however it’d be straightforward sufficient to depart it set at 3 (it was additionally the one toaster oven that visibly toasted the bread on the lightest toast setting). I additionally appreciated that it was the one toaster oven of the bunch to function an “A Little Further” button for these instances when your toast wants one other minute.

In the meantime, the Toshiba’s toast was a bit of too gentle at 4 out of 6, and too gentle on the darkest setting, too.

The opposite 4 toaster ovens I examined all use timer knobs with little markers for various settings. I am not a fan of the strategy, particularly with a mannequin just like the Hamilton Seaside 31123D, which places tiny markers for medium and darkish toast straight adjoining to at least one one other on the dial. Although a full 3 minutes of toasting time separates them, you may should stoop down, squint and switch the knob very rigorously if you wish to hit something in between the 2 with any type of consistency.

The very best of the guide management bunch? That’d be the Oster TSSTTVCG05, which persistently delivered satisfying golden brown toast at medium settings in much less time than Bialetti, and which additionally options the perfect setting for folk who like toast darkish, however not charcoal black.


Ry Crist/CNET

Talking of the darkest setting, I did not begrudge the toaster ovens that burnt the hell out of my bread, as a result of that darkest setting is commonly wanted to toast from frozen. To place that to the take a look at, I toasted a number of batches of frozen Eggo waffles in every toaster on the darkest setting. Predictably, those that had produced black toast on the identical setting did the perfect job, although the Black & Decker toaster oven’s Eggos have been a bit of too effectively finished on the darkest setting, too. That’ll power you to seek for a candy spot between medium and darkish on the devoted doneness dial if you’re toasting frozen meals.

In the meantime, the weakest toasters of the bunch — Hamilton Seaside and Toshiba — weren’t capable of get the Eggos fairly crisp sufficient. They may have benefited from Bialetti’s “A Little Further” button.

When following the directions on the field, Black & Decker and Oster gave us the best-cooked frozen pizzas.

Ry Crist/CNET

Pizza and different frozen snacks and meals

I additionally baked a bunch of frozen pizzas — personal-sized pepperoni pies from DiGiorno, to be particular. The field recommends baking a frozen pizza at 425 F for 17 minutes, so that is what I did with every toaster oven. 

The outcomes have been throughout place, however not terribly shocking. The Hamilton Seaside toaster oven was a bit of wimpy within the toast assessments, and it adopted go well with right here, too, with an underbaked pizza that wanted one other couple of minutes within the oven. In the meantime, the toaster oven with probably the most energy — the Bialetti — gave us burnt pizza that cooked quite a bit sooner than you’d count on.

Toshiba burnt the pizza, too. That was extra shocking because it had the other drawback throughout my toast assessments. Like Bialetti, it provides a devoted pizza setting. With each fashions, the outcome was principally an identical — burnt pizza when following the field directions.

The very best-cooked pizzas of the bunch got here from Oster and Black & Decker, whereas the brilliant purple, retro-designed Nostalgia toaster oven baked a satisfactory pie, too.

Along with DiGiorno’s, I made certain to check numerous different frozen snacks and meals, together with mozzarella sticks (quick bake time), Pizza Bagels (medium baking time) and waffle fries (lengthy baking time). Once more, for probably the most half, I used to be much less involved with how issues tasted than I used to be with how a lot every toaster oven matched the beneficial temperature and prepare dinner instances in contrast with the person’s guide. The outcomes largely lined up with what we noticed from the pizzas, however if you wish to learn extra particulars, you may try my full testing notes here.

Ry Crist/CNET

Convection cookies

My final assessments have been an workplace favourite: Nestle Tollhouse chocolate chip cookies. I baked 5 cookies at a time in every toaster oven at its convection setting and in keeping with the beneficial time and temperature settings.

The Toshiba toaster oven once more produced an overcooked outcome, which match the sample — it undercooked throughout toast assessments and overcooked throughout baking and broiling assessments. Bialetti and Black & Decker’s cookies have been barely effectively finished, too. In the meantime, Nostalgia, Oster and Hamilton Seaside produced our style testers’ high cookies (they handed the attention take a look at with my Twitter followers, too). 

Nostalgia’s convection setting gave us probably the most even bake on cookies — a notable distinction from the usual baking assessments, the place Nostalgia tended to prepare dinner sooner within the again. 

In honesty, although, the entire toaster ovens did fairly effectively on the convection setting — it is a function that actually makes a distinction with baked items like cookies. In truth, all of them can bake cookies or the rest simply the way in which you want. Those that overcook or undercook will simply require extra of a studying curve.

To that finish, the Oster toaster oven emerged as my high choose from a efficiency standpoint — it aced my toast assessments and proved predictable all through all of my baking and broiling assessments, too. That stated…

Do not get burned by dangerous design

I’ve but to check a toaster oven that makes meals style any higher than a full-size oven would. They’re merely not designed to carry out to that customary — particularly not for lower than $100.

That is why I believe you must take most toaster oven efficiency claims with a grain or two of salt. So long as your toaster oven does not overcook or undercook meals an excessive amount of, and if it has sufficient energy (1,500 watts is an efficient benchmark for average-sized convection toaster ovens), then you definitely will not discover a lot of a distinction in the way in which it cooks meals as in contrast with different fashions prefer it.

You will discover design flaws and clunky person interfaces, although, so should you can, head to the shop and get your fingers on the fashions you are zeroing in on before you purchase. Open and shut the doorways, modify the racks — search for the little issues. As an illustration, the glass door on the top-performing Oster mannequin opens down greater than 90 levels, which implies that the glass can clank straight towards the nook of your countertop if you do not have it pushed up towards your backsplash.

As for me, I hated the imprecise doneness dials on the Hamilton Beach and Nostalgia toaster ovens, and I used to be additionally bugged by the temperature dial on the Toshiba model, which begins at 350 levels Fahrenheit and strikes in 20-degree increments — meaning you may’t hit a exact 400.

None of those countertop toaster ovens is ideal, however some on this worth vary look higher than others, and really feel a lot simpler to make use of. These are variations price buying round for.

You may additionally need to take into consideration what you may be utilizing your toaster oven for most frequently. When you like toast together with your espresso every morning, prioritize a toaster oven with a exact preset. When you wish to broil issues like hamburgers, ensure you get a toaster oven with a excessive high rack place 2 or 3 inches beneath the heating parts. Many do not allow you to set the racks any greater than midway up, which is just too low from the heating parts for a very good char.

What about my vitality invoice?

One argument in favor of countertop toaster ovens is that they use much less vitality than a full-size conventional oven. That is true — most full-size electrical ovens will draw about 2,400 watts at medium to high heat, whereas the common toaster oven will draw round 1,500 watts. That implies that each time you are utilizing your toaster oven as an alternative of your full-size oven, you are chopping your vitality consumption by a bit of over a 3rd.

What does that imply in {dollars} and cents? Let’s stroll by the mathematics. Assuming an vitality charge of $0.12 per kilowatt hour and a median use of 1 hour per day, the full-size oven will add about $105 to your energy bill each year. Unplug the oven and use a toaster oven as an alternative, and that yearly energy cost drops to $65.

Your precise financial savings will fluctuate based mostly on use, and can doubtless be quite a bit lower than $40. In any case, most individuals who personal toaster ovens will proceed to make use of their full-size oven typically, if not more often than not, and hardly any of us will cease utilizing our ovens altogether. So let’s cut up the distinction and say that utilizing a toaster oven as an alternative of a full-size oven a minimum of some of the time can knock as a lot as $20 off of your yearly vitality invoice, supplied you are baking one thing nearly day-after-day.

That is nonetheless fairly good, however it’s additionally lower than you would possibly count on. Give it some thought — the common 1,500-watt toaster oven provides about 0.6 cubic ft on the within, whereas the common 2,400-watt electrical oven provides about 5 cubic ft. The toaster oven is 85 p.c smaller, however it’s solely utilizing 35 p.c much less vitality. When you’ve obtained a household to feed, or should you wish to make a number of batches of cookies at a time, then you definitely’ll truly get extra worth from the full-size oven.


Tyler Lizenby/CNET

Are there sensible toaster ovens?

There certain are — effectively, sensible countertop ovens, anyway — however it’s very early, and so they’re very costly. Except you are an enthusiastic early adopter of sensible kitchen tech with lots of money to burn, they’re robust to suggest, and I would follow a daily oven.

The primary to reach was the June Intelligent Oven, which now sells in a second-gen mannequin for $599. It is a succesful cooking machine that makes use of built-in cameras to determine what you are making an attempt to make, and it provides cooking steerage and an abundance of settings to tweak in its companion app. It additionally is not good at making toast.

The Tovala Smart Oven is one other second-gen sensible oven, and at $299, it is inexpensive than June. It does not function built-in cameras — as an alternative, this sensible oven makes use of a built-in QR code scanner to determine particular Tovala meal kits, in addition to as much as 750 frozen meals from retailers like Trader Joe’s. From there, the sensible oven automates the whole cooking course of. You simply put the meals in and press begin.

The Brava Oven is a succesful related cooker — however it prices $995.

Tyler Lizenby/CNET

The third sensible oven price mentioning comes from Brava, and it is the costliest of the three at $995. Amongst toaster oven upgrades, it’s kind of like Frankenstein’s monster — you get the identical infrared heating parts because the Panasonic FlashXpress, the identical built-in cameras as June, and the identical meals equipment strategy as Tovala. Just like the sensible oven itself, these meal kits are awfully costly, with dinner for 2 starting from $28 to $45.


Whirlpool’s sensible oven is on the market now for $799.

Chris Monroe/CNET

I do not suppose any of those sensible choices are price shopping for but, however related cooking devices are persevering with to mature — and with merchandise just like the Instantaneous Pot proving that there is nonetheless a wholesome urge for food for well-featured kitchen tech and kitchen home equipment, producers are motivated to innovate. 

That features the market-movers. Whirlpool has a smart countertop oven of its own now, and extra large manufacturers are prone to comply with go well with. Only in the near past, LG announced that its smart ovens will support Tovala’s meals kits — although you may must scan their QR codes with the Tovala app in your cellphone. And should you’re available in the market for a microwave, you would possibly think about the $250 Amazon Smart Oven, which principally combines a microwave with an air fryer and provides in built-in Alexa voice controls.

It is not sensible, however should you’d reasonably splurge on a elaborate pop-up toaster, the $300 Revolution R180 truly left us impressed and charmed once we examined it out.

Molly Worth/CNET

Heck, even plain previous toasters wish to seize consideration. The newest is the Revolution R180, a $300 toaster with a touchscreen on the entrance. Curiously, that one makes use of diamond-shaped heating coils which can be sooner and extra environment friendly than conventional toaster coils, and it labored as marketed once we examined it out. I’m wondering if we’ll see related designs begin to pop up within the toaster oven class.

Recent competitors like which may result in one thing really compelling — and, on the very least, it ought to ultimately assist to carry costs right down to extra cheap ranges. After we get to that time, I will replace this part to incorporate our high choose with its execs and cons.

Extra scrumptious shopping for recommendation

Recent Articles

We requested, you instructed us: This is how lengthy your display timeout is ready for

Credit score: Ryan-Thomas Shaw / Android AuthoritySetting your display timeout is a simple method to tame pointless battery usage in your Android cellphone. Set...

Ballot: How usually do you improve your iPhone? – 9to5Mac

A latest survey confirmed that one among three clients plan to stay with their iPhone for at least more than three years. Because the...

Sensor Tower’s Q1 2021 Information Digest: Finance App Installs Surged 34% Yr-Over-Yr within the U.S. and Europe

Sensor Tower’s newest quarterly Information Digest, available now, is a deep dive into the state of the worldwide app ecosystem...

Related Stories

Stay on op - Ge the daily news in your inbox